top of page

Dr. Willie Soon's interview by Tucker Carlson (December 2023)

Updated: Jan 10



In December 2023, CERES-Science co-founder, Dr. Willie Soon, was invited to talk to Tucker Carlson about energy policy, climate change and approaches to science.

The full interview covered a lot of topics and lasted 48 minutes.


The interview was posted online on January 9th, 2024 and is available to view on Tucker Carlson's website at the following link: https://tuckercarlson.com/the-tucker-carlson-encounter-fossil-fuels/

Or it can be viewed on Twitter/X.com at:


[Update January 10th, 2024:] It can also be viewed on YouTube below:



TIMESTAMP HEADLINE

00:01:49 Fossil Fuels in Space

00:14:27 Global Warming Throughout History

00:25:31 Outside Forces are Ruining Science

00:40:41 Evidence of God


Further reading on the topics discussed


Dr. Soon's comments on the discussion of the origin of fossil fuels

In the first part of the interview, Tucker Carlson asked Dr. Soon some questions about the possibility that hydrocarbons (gas, oil and coal) could be produced "abiogenically" as opposed to requiring a biological source.


Gas, oil and coal are commonly referred to as "fossil fuels". The term is based on the concept that all of these hydrocarbons where formed millions of years ago when prehistoric plants and animals died and were gradually buried by layers of rock. That is, they are supposedly all formed from the compression of biological "fossils" that became buried under ground for millions of years.


Dr. Soon was pointing out that there is considerable evidence that this is not the only way that hydrocarbons can be produced:

  • For example, in a 2009 paper in Nature Geoscience, Kolesnikov and colleagues showed that under very high pressures and temperatures, methane gas can be converted into short-chained hydrocarbons (https://doi.org/10.1038/ngeo591).

  • Another example they discussed was the fact that liquid methane and small-chained hydrocarbons are found in Saturn's moon, Titan - see Mastrogiuseppe and colleagues (2019), Nature Astronomy; https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-019-0714-2; Hayes (2016). Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-earth-060115-012247.

  • Meanwhile, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons have also been found in Titan's atmosphere - see Zhao and colleagues (2018), Nature Astronomy, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-018-0585-y.

  • They also mentioned that multiple chlorinated hydrocarbons have been identified on Mars by the Curiosity rover - see Freissinet and colleagues (2015), Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets, https://doi.org/10.1002/2014JE004737.

  • Finally, several studies have suggested that PAHs (Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons) can also be formed in interstellar space (i.e., deep space in between stars). E.g., Dorian S. N. Parker and colleagues (2011), Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1113827108.


But what does all of this mean?


From Dr. Soon's perspective, it means we should be careful not to assume all of the hydrocarbons on Earth are "fossil fuels". We do not yet know what percentage of the Earth's hydrocarbons were formed from biological fossils and what percentage were formed from non-biological ("abiogenic") processes.


However, it should be stressed that this does not necessarily mean that our accessible hydrocarbon reserves are limitless. As Dr. Soon pointed out the conditions Kolesnikov and colleagues (2009) showed could produce hydrocarbons abiogenically occur very deep underground - at least 50-100 miles. In contrast, the deepest oil or gas drill so far have only been 6 to 8 miles deep.


Dr. Soon also pointed out that current drills are not able to extract 100% of the oil and gas in the reserves - as the oil or gas is extracted, the pressure required to extract more becomes greater until it eventually becomes impractical to remove (with current technology, including fracking).


So, in terms of practical gas, oil and coal exploration, arguably it does not make much difference how the hydrocarbons in the known reserves were produced. Moreover, most coal, oil and gas companies spend considerable financial resources in the exploration of new reserves. This shows that from an economic perspective, the companies that are most heavily invested in the existing reserves are actively seeking new potential sites to drill.


On the other hand, as Dr. Soon later discussed, the widespread debates over "limited resources" and "renewable energies" are often non-scientific and unrealistic.


For more details on some of the topics discussed, below is a background presentation in pdf format:


Background material for Tucker Carlson interview
.pdf
Download PDF • 5.52MB


23,805 views47 comments

47 Comments


I actually had a 1-on-1 Zoom meeting with Dr. Soon - a VERY nice man and so generous and helpful. To say nothing of incredibly well-informed and just plain smart!

Like
Replying to

Did you have to pay for it?

Like

Important, impactful interview! I’m very thankful to have heard what I intuitively believed/believe without having a science background. I have not trusted the political climate alarmists. I feel hopeful after hearing a real brilliant scientific thinker! Thank you to Tucker and Dr. Soon for delivering truth!

Like

Excellent interview and Dr Soon explained comlplex issues very clearly. I keep getting my comments deleted from Instgram whenever I refer to CERES-Science or Dr Soon. Social media platforms are censoring this information which shows how corrupted the system is. Dr Soon please go speak on more podcasts to get the message out, Joe Rogan & Jordan Peterson & PDB. Everyone needs to hear this message.

Like

Love Dr. Soon, thank you for telling they way it is. Campconstitution.net is great camp for whole family.

Like

I listened to this interview and it is impactful! Science has been "purchased" by companies/organizations that conclude that they have solutions for climate change (CO2 capture for example) that have no scientific basis. I appreciated the candor and clarity provided, I just hope we can overcome the calamitous decision-making of politicians and power hungry people.

Like
bottom of page